2026 CarGurus Top Rated Dealer | Dave Arbogast

We’re proud to announce that Dave Arbogast has been recognized as a 2026 Top Rated Dealer by CarGurus. This prestigious award reflects our team’s continued commitment to exceptional customer service and the trust our customers place in us every day.

While receiving an award is always exciting, this recognition is especially meaningful because it is rooted in customer feedback. It represents the experiences shared by the people who have visited our dealership, worked with our team, and trusted us with one of life’s most important purchases.

To everyone who took the time to leave a review, recommend Dave Arbogast, or return to us for another new or used vehicle: thank you. This award belongs to you just as much as it belongs to our team.

What Is the CarGurus Top Rated Dealer Award?

CarGurus is one of the most widely used automotive shopping platforms in the country, helping buyers research vehicles, compare prices, connect with dealerships, and make informed purchasing decisions.

The CarGurus Top Rated Dealer Award recognizes dealerships with a demonstrated record of providing outstanding customer experiences. Under the platform’s published criteria for the 2026 awards, qualifying dealerships must maintain an average rating of at least 4.5 out of 5 stars and receive a minimum number of customer reviews.
In other words, this recognition isn’t based solely on inventory size, sales volume, or advertising. It is driven by the opinions of real customers.

That is what makes being named a 2026 Top Rated Dealer such an honor. It shows that our dedication to treating people well is being noticed by the customers who matter most.

A Commitment That Goes Back Decades

Outstanding customer service has been the foundation of Dave Arbogast since the dealership’s earliest days.
Since 1992, we have grown from a local dealership into a trusted automotive destination serving Troy, Dayton, Piqua, Sidney, Springfield, Tipp City, Huber Heights, and communities throughout Ohio and beyond. Although our facilities, inventory, and services have expanded over the years, our guiding principle has remained the same: every customer deserves to be treated with honesty, respect, and genuine care.

We know that purchasing a vehicle can feel overwhelming. There are models to compare, financing decisions to make, and countless details to consider. Our job is to make that process easier.
That means listening before recommending, answering questions clearly, respecting each customer’s time, and helping people find a vehicle that genuinely suits their needs and budget. It also means continuing to support our customers after the sale through dependable automotive service, knowledgeable technicians, and a team that is ready to help whenever questions arise.

More Than a Transaction

For us, the automotive business has never been only about selling cars, trucks, SUVs, or vans. It is about building relationships.

A vehicle helps someone commute to a new job, take children to school, visit family, run a business, or set out on a long-awaited road trip. We understand the role that dependable transportation plays in everyday life, and we never take lightly the trust involved in helping someone choose the right vehicle.

That customer-first approach can be found throughout our dealership. It begins with a welcoming, low-pressure shopping experience and extends to financing, vehicle delivery, maintenance, repairs, and future purchases.
Whether a customer lives just down the road or several states away, our goal is to provide the same hometown feeling and personal attention. We want everyone who works with us to feel informed, comfortable, and confident in their decision.

This Recognition Belongs to Our Team

Becoming a CarGurus Top Rated Dealer requires a consistent effort from every part of the dealership.

Our sales professionals take the time to understand what each customer is looking for. Our finance team works to explain available options and make the paperwork as straightforward as possible. Our service and parts professionals help customers protect their vehicles and keep them performing at their best. Behind the scenes, many more team members work every day to make each visit smooth and enjoyable.

This award reflects their professionalism, knowledge, and willingness to go the extra mile. We are grateful to have a team that understands the importance of every conversation, every appointment, and every customer interaction.

Your Feedback Makes a Difference

Customer reviews do more than help a dealership earn recognition. They also help other shoppers decide where they can feel confident beginning their search.

When customers share their experiences, they provide valuable insight into what it is like to work with our team. Their feedback also helps us understand what we are doing well and where we can continue improving.
We appreciate every thoughtful review, referral, and recommendation. We read your feedback, share it with our team, and use it to keep raising the standard for the experience we provide.

Celebrating Today—and Looking Ahead

We are honored to be named a 2026 CarGurus Top Rated Dealer, but we view this award as more than a celebration of what we have accomplished. It is also a responsibility to continue earning our customers’ confidence with every visit.

Awards are meaningful, but trust must be earned one customer at a time. That is why we will continue focusing on knowledgeable assistance, transparent communication, quality vehicles, dependable service, and the personal attention our customers have come to expect.

From all of us at Dave Arbogast, thank you to our customers and community for making this recognition possible. We look forward to serving you for many years to come—and continuing to be Driven to Your Satisfaction.

Visit Dave Arbogast in Troy, Ohio, to explore our inventory, meet our award-winning team, or experience the customer service that helped make us a 2026 CarGurus Top Rated Dealer.